Wednesday, March 09, 2005

"Tokto is our land!" "Is not!" "Is, too!"

In the never ending Tokto-Takeshima row...

Never willing to just let things cool off for a while, South Korean Foreign Minister Ban Kimoon [Pan Kimun in McCune-Reischauer] said today that the Tokto issue "takes precedence over Korea-Japan relations." Yonhap describes this as South Korea being "prepared to risk its relations with Japan" over the Tokto issue.

Sovereignty is important, and this move is meant to get Japan to back off on its claims to the islets (and the surrounding territorial waters), but will this posturing be any more effective than such posturing in the past?

Again, I submit that Tokto, like Japan's territorial disputes with other countries, are part of the landscape and they aren't going to go away any time soon, especially not with the rhetoric and grandstanding coming from both the private and public sectors in both countries. What we need to realize is that other important issues (Hello? Regional security, North Korean nukes, a resurging China, and Yonsama!) should not be derailed over this.

4 Comments:

At 3/10/2005 4:45 AM, Blogger bluejives said...

Japan and Korea should negotiate some kind of joint custody of the island.

Either that or just flip a coin to see who gets it and put the issue to a long deserved rest.

 
At 3/10/2005 4:01 PM, Blogger nora sumi park said...

the real issue is maritime territory. just like with the spratleys where the territorial waters mean more access to oil and fish, in the east sea (aka sea of japan) there are fertile waters for fishing.

i have always thought myself that a solution might be japan acknowledging korean ownership of tokto in exchange for an agreement of korean and japanese territorial waters based on the distance between ullÅ­ng-do island and shimane island, rather than between tokto and shimane.

 
At 3/27/2005 4:17 PM, Anonymous singingcat said...

to bluejieves,
hmmm...
you may see Tokto-Takeshima problem not very seriously
however, Korea and Japan had fought about it for YEARS.
nd im pretty sure that it can't be solved peacefully from now on...
it's too late i guess.
Many people do hope it will be solved peacefully...

 
At 3/27/2005 4:17 PM, Anonymous singingcat said...

to bluejieves,
hmmm...
you may see Tokto-Takeshima problem not very seriously
however, Korea and Japan had fought about it for YEARS.
nd im pretty sure that it can't be solved peacefully from now on...
it's too late i guess.
Many people do hope it will be solved peacefully...

 

Post a Comment

<< Home